Regulating system



R. A. GEISELMAN REGULATING SYSTEM April 7, 1936.

Filed Nov. 8, 1934 INVENTOR WITNESSES:

Patented Apr. 7, 1936 PATENT OFFICE BEGULATING SYSTEM Ralph A. Geiselman, Forest Hills, Pa... 'assignor to Westinghouse Electric &: Manufacturing Company, East Pittsburgh, Pa, a corporation oi Pennsylvania Application November 8, 1934, Serial No. 752,067

9 Claims. (01.171-119) My invention relates to regulating systems and has particular relation to compensating means, capable of cycle error integration, for frequency regulators utilized to maintain the frequency of an alternating current system at that precise adjustment required for accurate time keeping service.

With the introduction of electric clocks and other synchronous time keeping devicesdisposed to be driven from alternating-current power circuits that supply lighting and appliance devices, the problem of accurately regulating the power system frequency within those close limits necessitated for accurate time keeping has become one of commercial importance. It is to an improved manner of solving this problem that my invention is directed.

One object of my invention is to provide means associated with a standard reference clock or other master time checking device which automatically adjusts'the setting of a power system frequency regulator in a manner that the average frequency of the system will be maintained at the value necessary to cause system energized clocks of the synchronous type to maintain ac curate time.

Another object oi my invention is the pro vision of a regulating system of the type de scribed in which cycle errors are checked and cor rected for'at regular time intervals.

A further object of my invention is the pro vision of compensating means for a frequency regulating system that functions in a manner that the lost and gained cycles will exactly cancel each other over a given period of time.

In practicing my invention, which is applicable to frequency regulating systems of all types capable of calibration adjustment, 1 provide a standard reference clock or other master time keeping device which momentarily completes a checking circuit at regular intervais of time. termediate the clock and he regulator '1" a time error integrating device which mess. the number of cycles actually produced by the regulated power system. If at the end oi. each checking period this number does not correspond to the total required number of cycles during the time elapsed, as measured by the'stanclard clock, the completion of the checking circuit functions to appropriately recalibrate the frequency segu later in a manner that the number of cycles produced by the power system durin he succeed= ing period will be changed in the opposite direction from that of the first period error. In this manner the average irequency oi the regulated power system over a plurality of checked periods will be maintained at the value necessary to efiect accurate time keeping.

My invention, together with additional objects and advantages will best be understood from the following description of a specific embodiment thereof when taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawing, in which Figure 1 is a diagrammatic view of apparatus and circuits illustrating the timeerror integrating compensating means applied to a regulator that is arranged to control the frequency 01 a prime-mover driven synchronous generator in accordance with my invention.

Fig. 2 is a view in end elevation of the error integrating device comprised by the system of Fig. l, in which the arrangement or the contact segments carried by the frequency responsive rotating drumand the stationary contact members cooperating therewith is illustrated, and

Fig. 3 is a diagram of curves illustrating the manner in which the compensating means 0! my invention functions to maintain the average Ireouency oi the regulated system at a predetermined or desired value.

Referring the drawing and particularly to Fig. thereof, the power system with which the regulator compensating means of my invention is shown, comprises an alternatingcurrent generator ii that driven a prime mover l2 shown as being of w actuated type. i The generator comprises armature windings directly connected the circuit conductors l4 c1! 9. power system and a direct current energized field winding IS.

The prime mover B2 is supplied with motive any suitable source (not shown) a conduit ill in which is disposed the a; valve Q8. The amount 01' openso is controlled in a well known medium of a speed responernoi st own as comprising a fly ball err. 263, driven by the prime mover, which .ines the position of a pivoted arm it with end of which the movable member of the input control valve is connected. This govmechanism functions to maintain the speed or" the prime mover approximately constan't.

A tension spring 23 is utilized to exert a biasing force upon the fly ball actuated lever 2i andis made adjustable in order to change the speed setting of the governor. The upper end M spring 23 is fixed to a threaded rod N which cooperates with an interlorly threaded gear wheel 25 arranged to be rotated by means of a suitable motor 21. The motor 27 is shown as comprising an armature Winding 29 and two differentially related field windings r and I. When energized from a direct current source, such as a battery 38 through winding 1', the motor rotates in a direction to raise the tension of spring 23, and thus increase the governor speed of the prime mover l2. Similarly-when energized through winding 1 the motor rotates in the opposite direction to lower the speed of the prime mover.

It will be recognized that changes in the prime mover speed effect corresponding changes in the frequency of the voltage supplied by the genorator ill to power circuit conductors M. This frequency may thus be maintained at a. desired value by providing means which appropriately energize the governor calibrating motor 2! upon variations the frequency from the desired "value, Such means is illustrated in Fig. 1 in the form of a frequency regulator 32, shown in an elementary and simplified form for the purposes of greater clarity.

As illustrated, the regulator 32 comprises a synchronous motor 38 which is energized through suitable potential transformers 35 from the power circuit l4. The motor which thus rotates at all times at a speed that is directly proportional to the power system frequency, drives a sensitive fly ball mechanism 31 which, by determining the position of the contact mem-- ber 38 carried by the pivoted arm 38, controls the operation of the governor calibrating motor 21. when the system frequency falls below the desired value, the contact member 38 is moved upwardly into engagement with a stationary member r, thereby completing an energizing circuit from the battery 38 for the motor 21 which causes the motor to recalibrate the primemover governor in the speed and frequency increasing direction. Similarly, when the system frequency rises above the desired value, contact member 38 of the regulator is moved downwardly into engagement with .a stationary contact member I to complete an energizing circuit for the motor 21 which effects a decrease in speed of prime mover i2 and a lowering of the power system frequency.

Regardless of how sensitive the frequency regulator 32 may be, it is found in practice that it is, impossible for it, at any given setting or calibration, to maintain the system frequency exactly at a desired or constant value, over a period of time during which thepower circuit conditions change, particularly, with respect to load demand. Consequently, an electric clock 42 of the synchronous type which is energized from the power circuit l4 will, in the absence of regulator compensating means, not keep exactly accurate time.

If, however, some means be provided whereby the errors in the regulated frequency may be accurately measured and the regulator be recalibrated from time to time not only to return to the desired average value of frequency but also to vary therefrom in the opposite direction from the original error for a time sufficient to neutralize the cycles lost or gained during the period of original error, the total number of cycles may, over a; plurality of such time periods, be controlled to correspond to that required to maintain accurate time by clock 42. The compensating system of my invention fulfills this requirement in a manner now to be explained.

calibration adjusting means shown in the form of a tension spring 44 which biases the contact carrying arm 39 upwardly. An increase in the tension of the spring 44 causes the regulator to raise the value of the frequency which it tends to maintain while a decrease in spring tension similarly allows the regulator to lower the regulated frequency. This spring tension is adjusted through the medium of a mechanism 48 which forms an essential element of the compensating system of my invention.

In conjunction with mechanism 46, I provide a standard reference clock 48 or equivalent master time keeping device for the purpose of completing at regular intervals an error checking circuit. To effect such circuit completion, 1 provide in association with the second hand 58 of the clock, a stationary contact member 8| which is engaged by the hand once during each revolution, or at intervals of one minute. This circuit completes, from a suitable source of energization such as a battery 53, an energizing-circuit for a regulator calibrating motor 58, when the regulated frequency has been in error during the preceding period. Such error is indicated by a synchronous motor 58 energized by the regulated circuit voltage through the transformer 88- which drives a segment carrying disk 88 which,

in conjunction with contact members carried by mounting posts R, L and C, appropriately routes the recalibration impulses to motor 56.

Motors 58 and 58 and contact making means a 88 all form a part of the error integrating mechanism 48, the mechanical construction of which will now be explained. The mechanism is shown as being supported from a suitable panel 82, preferably of insulating material, which is mounted in a vertical position. Carried by bearings 84 and 65 is a cradle'assembly comprising a pair of circular disks 81 and 88 which are mechanically spaced apart and secured together through the medium of tie rods 88. The entire cradle assembly may be rotated in its bearings 84 and 65 by operation of the motor 58 which drives a worm gear ll that meshes with a gear wheel 12, carried by the cradle shaft 13. The rotative movements of the cradle are transmitted through the gear wheels 75 and 16 to a bell crank lever 58 (Fig. 2) carried on the end of shaft 18. The

free end of the arm 18 is connected by any suiti able means, such as a rod 88, with the regulator -..calibrating spring 44.

gear 88, a gear wheel 81, and a shaft 88 on which is mounted the segment-carrying disk 88 before mentioned. This shaft is supported at its two ends by means of bearings 88 and 8| which permit it to freely rotate in accordance with the driving speed of synchronous motor 58. The disk 60, which is preferably of insulating material, carries on its outerperiphery, a pair of conducting material segments 83 and 84, which are more clearly shown in Fig. 2. Bearing against the outer periphery of the segment carrying disk in the relative positions shown are contact members or brushes 81 and 88, respectively, carsupported mounting studs C,

The synchronous motor 58 and the gear train through which it drives the segment carrying disk egomace I 3 are so designed that at the desired or proper average frequency of the regulated system, the disk 60 will rotate at such a speed that, upon each completion of the error checking circuit by the standard reference clock 48, the two conducting material segments 93 and 94 willoccupy the symmetrical position shown with respect to contact brush 98 in which the brush bears against the disk 60 at a point on its periphery intermediate the two separated segments. For this condition;

the energizing circuit of the regulator calibrating motor 56 set up by the second hand of clock 48 cannot be completed.

I Hence, in the operation of the compensating system of my invention, so long as the regulated frequency is of the proper or desired value, no change in the calibration of the'frequency regulator will be effected upon the engagement of the contact members 50 and 5!. Suppose, however, that because of an increase in load on the generator iii, the frequency decreases slightly, the synchronous motor 58 will run at a come spondingly slower speed and, at the end of the period when the error checking is enacted, it

will not have made the required number of revolutions to bring the two segments 93 and 94, into the neutral positions with respect to the brush member 955.

Assuming the rotation of the disk 60 to be counter clockwise, as indicated by the arrow in Fig. 2, the contact segment 93 will, upon completion of the checking circuit by the clock 48, be in a lag ging position in which it is engaged by the brush segments 95 and 9'5; This engagement completes an energizing circuit for the motor 58 that ex tends from one side of the battery 53 through conductor E00, contact member 59, the second hand 50 of the clock 8, conductor till, the urn per blade of a switch I03, conductor 508, mount ing stud C and brush contact 86 carried thereby, the segment 93, "crush contact 81 and its supporting stud R, and conductor 05 to the motor 5% through its terminal R, then from the middle terminal of the motor through conductor I06 and the lower blade of the switch 33 to the other side of battery 53.

Thus energized, the motor 56 rotates to ad- ,iust the regulator in a frequency-raising disco tion and causes the'cradle 61-458 to he rotative iy shifted in the direction indicated by arrow R" in Fig. '2; The period of time during which this energization is maintained is relatively small because of the fact that the checking circuit main= Gil not he suificient t bring @1 L ing, upon the next setting up of tained by the clock 48 is almost immediately interrupted and the further fact that the segments carried by the disk 60 of the mechanism 45 are rapidly rotating. The amount of the cradle shift is, however, sumcient to effect a substantial movemerit oi the spring controlling arm I8 in an no ward direction which serves to raise the value of frequency which the regulator 32 will main This shift in the cradle at the same time o the position of the segment carryir L be advanced to an extent which 7 neutral position upon the next s time checking circ i t, as will be explained.

in a similar manner, when ti cuit frequency is caused to rise as rota-"ms at a correspondingly f2" circuit by the clock 48, the se the disk to, to occupy act in the directions rotation of the disk in which position it engagesthe brush contacts 08 and 00. This engagement completes an energizing circuit for the regulator calibrating motor 56 which extends from the battery 53 through the conductor 5 I00, contact members 50 and 5| of the clock 48, conductor IN, the switch I03, conductor I04, brush contact 90 carried by the mounting stud C, the segment 94, brush contact 90 carried by the mounting stud L, conductor I08, motor 56, 10 through terminal'L, and conductor I 00 back to the battery--53. 1

Thus energized, the motor 56 rotates in the regulator frequency-lowering direction and shifts the position of the cradle in the direction indicated l5 by L in Fig. 2. As a result of this shiit, the spring controlling arm 58 moves downwardlyto lower the tension of the calibrating spring 44. This causes the regulator to maintain a lower irequency during the succeeding period. The shift in cradle position also correspondingly shifts the rotative position of segment carrying disk 80 in the backward direction L In addition to correcting the frequency of the svstem. upon its variation from the desired ever age value. the compensating system oi my invention acids or subtracts the cycles lost or gained by the g nerator. and acts upon the frequency regulator in a manner that these error cycles are eliminated during succeeding checking periods, 39 s that over a substantial number of periods. the total number of cycles will be that required to cause t e time indications of the system driven cock 4'1 to cor espond to those of the master clock i8. cliched is shown by the curves of Fig. 3. Assume the first considered condition in which the frequency oi the regulated generator I0 drops below the desired value between the error checking instants o and c. As a result of this lowering of 40 the frequency, there will be lost. during period 11-47, a number of cycies represented by the shaded area. below the desired or proper average value of frequency F8.

Upon the completion oi the error checking circult, at instant o, the integrating mechanism 46 effects a recalibration oi the i'requency regul to 32 which causes it to maintain a somewhat h) frequency during the pe iod 13-42. If it ha as is represented b Fig. 3, that this higher re is suificient to regain during this period as lost during period o-h', the average and upon thecompleticn circuit at time c, the later will he readies frequency is so The manner in which this is accom equivalent mechanism illustrated generally at I I5 may instead be utilized. To shift the control of the integrating mechanism 46 from clock 48 to time keeping device II5, the blades of switch I03 may be moved to their upper positions.

As illustrated, the device II5 comprises a pendulum I I6 suspended by a suitable knife edge from a stationary support Ill and arranged to be driven by means of a magnet II8 which derives its energization from a battery I I9 upon engagement of the contact members I20, which engagemcnt takes place when the pendulum is at its right-hand limit of swing. Energization of the winding I I8 exerts an attractive force upon a. piece of magnetic material I22 which assists the penduium in swinging back to the left-hand limit of travel, and in this manner the pendulum is continuously driven.

Fositioned on the lower tip of the pendulum is contact member 125 which, in the central position of the pendulum as illustrated, makes contact with a suitable stationary member shown as a mercury pool I26. Engagement of members I25 and I26 completes an energizing circuit for the actuating winding of a relay. I 30 from a source of energy, shown as a battery I23. Consequently, in the operation of the pendulum mach swing past the central position causes the movable member of the relay I 30 to be actuated upwardly. Thisring I31, carried by the drum shaft, and to a brush member I36.

Each time the contact member I rotates to the position illustrated, it engages a stationary contact member I38 and closes one point of a time-checking circuit in a manner similar to the operation of the clock 48, which has already been explained. This checking circuit is completed for a moment only by a contact member I40 carried by the pawl actuating relay I30.

Inasmuch as the operation of the complete compensating system of my invention is identical when the equipment H5 is used as when the clock 48 is utilized, no further detailed explanation thereof will here be made.

Although, I have shown and described certain specific embodiments of my invention, I am fully aware that many modifications thereof are possible. My invention is not to be restricted, therefore, except insofar as is necessitated by the prior art and by the scope of the appended claims.

I claim as my invention:

l. A compensating system for a frequency reg ulator comprising, in combination, a motor for adjusting the calibration of the regulator, a rotatable drum'carrying on opposite halves of its periphery two circumferentially separated contact segments, a pair of stationarily mounted contact brushes disposed to bear against said drum at points on its periphery separated by an angular distance less than the circumferential length of each contact segment, a master time-keeping device having associated therewith a pair of contact members which it momentarily closes at' regularly recurring time intervals, synchronous means, energized from the circuit whose frequency is being regulated, for driving said rotatable drum, and a circuit, which includes the contact members of the master time-keeping device and the contact brushes which bear against the segment-carrying drum, for energizing said calibration-adjusting motor.

2. A compensating system for a frequency regulator comprising, in combination, a'motor for adjusting the calibration of the regulator, a rotatable drum carrying on opposite halves of its periphery two circumferentially separated contact segments, a pair of. stationarily mounted contact brushes disposed to bear against said drum at points on its periphery separated by an angular distance less than the circumferential length of each contact segment, a master time-keeping device having associated therewith a pair of contact members which it momentarily closes at regularly recurring time intervals, synchronous means, energized by the voltage whose frequency is being regulated, for driving said rotatable drum, and a circuit, which includes the contact members of the master time-keeping device and the contact brushes which bear against the segmentcarrying drum, for energizing said calibration-adlusting motor, said synchronous means being so proportioned with respect to the master timekeeping device that when the regulated voltage passes through the desired number of cycles during each interval between successive contact closures by the time-keeping device the segmentcarrying drum will, at the instant of contact closure, occupy a position in which neither of the two segments engages both of the associated contact brushes.

3. A compensating system for a frequencyregulator, having associated therewith a calibrationadjusting motor, comprising, in combination, a rotatable drum having a pair of circumferentially separated contact segments disposed on opposite halves of its periphery, three stationarily mounted contact brushes disposed to bear against said drum at points on its periphery so separated that the angular distance between the intermediate or common brush and each of the remaining two brushes is less than the circumferential length of each contact segment, a master time-keeping device having associated therewith a pair of contact members which it momentarily closes at regularly recurring time intervals, synchronous means, energized by the voltage whose frequency is being regulated, for driving said rotatable drum, and a circuit which includes the contact members of the time-keeping device, the common contact brush which nears against the drum, and that associated brush which is positioned beyond the common brush in the direction of drum rotation, for energizing said calibration-adjusting motor in the frequencyraising direction.

4. A compensating system for a frequency regulator, having associated therewith a calibration- I adjusting motor, comprising, in combination, a rotatable drum having a pair of circinnferentially separated contact segments disposed on opposite halves of its periphery, three stationarily mounted contact brushes disposed-to bear against said drum at points on its periphery so separated that the angular distance between the intermediate and a circuit includes the contact members of the time-keeping device, the common contact brush which bears against the drum, and that associated brush which is positioned ahead of the common brush in the direction of drum rotation, for. energizing said calibration-adjusting motor in the frequency-lowering direction.

5. A compensating system for a frequency regulater, having associated therewith a calibrationadjusting motor, comprising, in combination, a rotatable drum having a pair of circumferentially separated contact segments disposed on opposite halves of its periphery three stationarily mounted contact brushes disposed to bear against said drum at points on its periphery so separated that the angular distance between the intermediate or common brush and each of the remaining two brushes is less than the circumferential length of each contact segment, a master time-keeping device having associated therewith a pair of contact members which it momentarily closes at regularly recurring time intervals, synchronous means, energized by the voltage whose frequency is being regulated, for driving said rotatable drum at such a speed that when the regulated voltage passes through the desired number of cycles during each interval between successive contact closures by the time- Keeping device the drum will, at the instant of such closure, occupy a position in which neither of its two segments is engaged by the said common contact brush associated therewith, a circuit which includes the contact members of the time-keeping device, the common contact brush for the drum, and that associated brush which is positioned beyond the common brush in the direction of drum rotation, for energizing said calibration-adjusting motor in the frequencyraising direction, and a circuit which similarly includes the contact members of the time-keeping device, the common contact brush for the drum and the remaining associated brush, which is positioned ahead of the common brush in the direction of drum rotation, for energizing said calibratiomadjusting motor in the frequencylowering direction.

6. A compensating system for a frequency regulator comprising, in combination, a calibrationadjusting motor for the regulator, a rotatably mounted structure operably connected with said motor, a synchronous motor, energized by the voltage whose frequency is being regulated, carried within said structure, a drum, having its axis of rotation coincident with that of the said structure, disposed to be driven by said synchronous motor, said drum having two circumferentially separated contact segments respectively disposed on opposite halves of its periphery, a pair of stationarily mounted contact brushes disposed to bear against said drum at points separated by a circumferential distance which is less than the circwnferential length of each contact segment, a master time-keeping device having associated therewith a pair of contact members which it momentarily closes at regularly recurring time intervals, and a circuit, which includes the contact members of the time-keeping device and the contact brushes associated with the segmentcarrying drum, for energizing said calibrating adjusting motor.

7. A compensating system for a frequency regulator comprising, in combination, a calibrationadlusting motor for the regulator, a rotatabiy mounted structure operably connected with said motor, a synchronous motor, energized by the voltage whose frequency is being regulated, carried within said structure, a drum, having its axis of rotation coincident with that of the said structure, disposed to be driven by said synchronous motor, said drum having two circumferentially separated contact segments respectively disposed on opposite halves of its periphery, a pair of stationarily mounted contact brushes disposed to bear against said drum at points separated by a circumferential distance which is less than the circumferential length of each contact segment, a master time-keeping device having associated therewith a pair of contact members which it momentarily closes at regularly recurring time intervals, and a circuit, which includes the contact members of thetime-keeping device and the contact bru:'hes associated with the segment-carrying drum, for energizing said calibration-adjusting motor, the speed of said drum being such that when the regulated voltage passes through the desired number of cycles during each interval between successive contact closures by the mekeeping device, the drum will, at the in tant of such contact closure, occupy a position in which neither of the two segments engages ooth of the associated contact brushes.

8. A compensating system for a frequency regulator comprising, in combination, a rotatable drum having a pair of circumferentially separated contact segments disposed on opposite halves of its periphery, three stationarily mounted contact brushes disposed to bear against said drum at points on its periphery so separated that the angular distance between the intermediate or common brush and each of the remaining two brushes is less than the circumferential length of each contact segment, a master time-keeping device having associated therewith a pair of contact members which it momentarily closes at regularly recurring time intervals, a calibration-adjusting motor for the regulator, a rotatable structure, mounted with its axis of rotation coincident with that of said segment-carrying drum, operably connected with said motor, a synchronous motor, energized by the voltage under control or the frequency regulator, carried within said structure and disposed to drive said segment-carrying drum at such a speed that when the regulated voltage passes through the desired number of cycles during each interval between successive contact closures by the time-keeping device the drum will, at the instant of such closure occupy, a position in which neither of its two segments is engaged by the said common contact brush associa'ted therewith, and a circuit which includes the contact members of the time-keeping device, the common contact brush for the drum, and that associated brush which is positioned beyond the common brush in the direction of drum rotation, for energizing said calibration-adjusting motor in the frequency-raising direction,

9. A compensating system for a frequency regulator comprising, in combination, a. rotatable drum having a pair of circumferentially separated contact segments disposed on opposite halves of its periphery, three stationarily mounted contact brushes disposed to bear against said drum at points on its periphery so separated that the angular distance between the intermediate or common brush and each of the remaining two brushes is less than the circumferential length of each contact segment, a master time-keeping device having associated therewith a pair of contact members which it momentarily closes at regularly recurring time intervals, a calibration-adjusting motor for the regulator, a rotatable structure, mounted with its axis of rotation coincident with that of said segment-carrying drum, operably connected with said motor, a synchronous motor, energized by the voltage under control 0! the frequency regulator, carried within said structure and disposed to drive said segment-carrying drum at such a speed that when the regulated voltaBe passes through the desired number of cyclesduring each interval between successive contact closures by the time-keeping device the drum will, at the instant of such closure occupy,

a position in which neither of its two segments is engaged by the said common contact brush associated therewith, and a circuit which includes the contact members of the time-keeping device, the

common contact brush for the drum and that associated brush which is positioned ahead of the common brush in the direction of drum rotation, for energizing said calibration-adjusting motor in the frequency-lowering direction.

RALPH s omsmmm. 

